Monday, March 9, 2009

Willy's Success

In class last week, we devoted a significant portion of the discussion to the question: what does it mean to be successful? We also talked about the relationship between success and happiness. I would like to expand on both of these questions in my blog:
One point that was argued in class was how success could be measured. Should it be by how much money one makes? How prestigious/well respected one’s job is? Or does it come from raising a happy family? I think the question of how to measure success can be broken down in to success in one’s career and success in one’s personal life. Willy seems to place most of the importance on his job; yet, his proudest accomplishment appears to be his son Biff. I believe Willy’s identity and feeling of self-worth are based on two different things: his ability as a salesman and Biff’s respect. The first thing, his ability as a salesman, is never really understood by Willy or by the reader. It is hard to tell whether or not Willy was ever actually a good salesman, although it is made very clear that at the end of his life he was not. His son’s respect is more clear-cut: he has it until his son seems him with The Woman, and then he loses it completely. Because by the present day neither of the things that give him a feeling of self-worth exists, it is understandable that he becomes so depressed and disconnected from reality. Willy is a failure no matter how he measures it; after all, he has been unsuccessful in both his home and his work.
We also talked about the relationship between happiness and success. I think Willy sees being happy as a natural offshoot of being successful. If it is true that Willy sees Biff’s respect as a sign of his own success, then we can clearly see how happy being successful makes Willy. After all, he is at his happiest when he talks to young Biff. Also, whenever he reminisces about how well he has done in sales, he is upbeat. In fact, these are just about the only two instances where Willy appears satisfied. One of Willy’s problems may be that he places too much importance on being successful.

6 comments:

Mark said...

Richie,
Interesting blog... you make a good point that Willy is constantly obsessed with his idea of success. I think we have very different views of what success actually is than Willy, or even his sons, do. You're right: Willy never makes a distinction between happiness and success. Great job!

Mark Zhang said...

When I read your litany of qualifications that are necessary to be "successful," I agreed with every single one, meaning that Willy was a loser.

Thanks for confirming what I already knew.

Jamarkus Zhang

Andrew Chang said...

We discussed this in class but I believe Willy bases his success off of what other people think about him, which seems to be the main reason for his failure in life in general. A good way to measure this success would be along the Greenberg scale but as I am not an experienced statistician, you will have to refer to Matt or John for an actual conversion. I do know that Willy's fears about peer evaluation make him extremely unsuccessful. Good points though otherwise.

- Andrew

Janey Zitomer said...

richie,
good blog; I feel like you did a good job on expanding upon a topic that had been taking us in circles in class and I agree to you that Willy does not only value his job as a salesman but also Biff's respect. (I hadn't really thought about the Biff respect thing before but it is so true)

JessicaGordon said...

Richie,

I like your analysis of how Willy identifies with not only his job but also with the respect that Biff can give him. Likewise, I agree that success is relative, but then again Willy really was not successful because he lost respect from his son and seemingly failed at his job. Lastly, I like how you acknowledge the things that do make Willy happen, aka his job and talking to Biff, because it shows that success and happiness are related. Great blog!

Elliot Ginsburg said...

Ritchie I enjoyed the brevity of your blog. Personally, I would use the Greenberg barometer of success to determine Willy's ineptitude but your examples aren't too shabby either. If you refer to my blog you will see my reasons for disagreeing with your ideas of Willy as a failure with respect to his fatherhood.

Toodles